The Elder Scrolls 6has an enormous legacy to live up to.Skyrimwas hugely critically and commercially successful, selling over 20 million copies between 2011 and 2014. Despite this, it is not a game without its problems.
ForThe Elder Scrolls 6to succeed, it will need to solve some ofSkyrim’s biggest issues to step out from its shadow and provide a truly next-gen-feeling RPG story. There’s one element in particular which the next game will need to improve upon to give players an exciting and freshElder Scrollsexperience.
RELATED:Will the Blades Return in Elder Scrolls 6?
Skyrim’s Choices
One ofSkyrim’s biggest problems is that, when it gives the player choices, the game very rarely gives the player reason to give those choices equal consideration. For example, in the opening sequence the player character is famously almost executed by the Imperial army after being caught up in aStormcloakambush on the Cyrodiil border.
In that same introduction, afterthe dragon Alduinattacks and disrupts the execution, the player is presented with the choice of following Ralof the Stormcloak who they were imprisoned with, or Hadvar, an Imperial soldier. The problem is that so far, Ralof has been the player character’s only sympathetic window into the world around them, while Hadvar literally helps administrate their almost-execution, albeit with a dour face.
As a result the choice exists, but it makes so little sense in almost any role-playing context for the player to go with Hadvar. Indeed, Hadvar doesn’t even promise to free or pardon the player if they go with him, something which could provide a motive to chooseSkyrim’s Imperialsover the rebels in the hope of gaining clemency with the more powerful political force. Without this motive, one of the only reasons a player might go with the Imperial soldier is because they know the Empire from the previous games.
There’s a similar choice problem when choosing the player’srace inSkyrim. For players unfamiliar withThe Elder Scrollsseries, the wide array of races available during character customization might come as a bit of a shock. In the introduction, the player only meets humans, with some Thalmor high elves seen at a distance. The only sympathetic character introduced by this point is still Ralof, and that combined with the Skyrim marketing materials make choosing a Nord, at least for the player’s first character, seem like the only truly immersive choice.
Compare this toOblivion, where the character starts off in the Imperial prison across from a Dark Elf, immediately introducing them to some of the diversity of the province they’re in. This makes playing as any race inOblivionseem more immersive, as compared toSkyrimit doesn’t feel like the game was designed with a particular race for the protagonist in mind.
RELATED:The Elder Scrolls 6 Should Double Down on One Major Oblivion Feature
The Future of The Elder Scrolls
The Elder Scrolls 6’s player characterneeds choices like these to feel like they’re given equal weight. There should not be one choice which the game makes far more appealing than the others or seems to want the player to make. Otherwise the choices in the game are plentiful, but they’re too easy to make for them to feel anything other than arbitrary.
The nextElder Scrollsgame should be designed to make choices like these have equal immersive weight. There should be an emotional appeal to both options when presented with a choice like the one between Ralof and Hadvar,the Stormcloaksor the Empire. When it comes to character’s race, the game should make the effort to ensure that the different options feel just as legitimate at the time of character creation.
This could be helped by the fact thatThe Elder Scrolls 6is rumored to take place in Hammerfell, which is divided between the Aldmeri Dominion and the Redguard between the events ofOblivionandSkyrim. This could make one race seem less like the main character of the game, and, as inOblivion, give the player more incentive to choose a race other than the natives of the province. In any case, Bethesda needs to ensure that different roleplaying choices feel as legitimate in the story if its next game is going to escapeSkyrim’s shadow.
The Elder Scrolls 6is in development.
MORE:Elder Scrolls 6’s Story Can Learn One Big Thing From Fallout 4
